Wicked Sharp Cheddar Cheese

(14)

$29.99

Calef’s Country Store

Crumbly texture with crystals (tyrosine) starting to form, delicious, sold by the lb.

6 in stock

Product Details

Calef’s features many varieties of “Snappy Old Cheddar” with varying degrees of sharpness. As a cheddar ages it loses moisture, becomes crumblier, begins to crystalize (tyrosine) and gets sharper in flavor.

Our Cheddar scale, least sharp to stand up and take notice:

  • Sharp – the opposite of it’s name this is our mildest offering
  • Extra Sharp – A bit sharper but still considered a mild cheese.
  • Rat Trap – Our best seller. Creamy, a bit sharp. Cut from hand packed 40LB wheels.
  • Super Sharp – Still creamy but a bit sharper after bite
  • Rugged Cheddar – As the name implies, has some bite. A good start on your aged cheddar journey.
  • 3 Year Aged – Aged at least 3 years, crystals and crumbly texture starting to develop.
  • Wicked Sharp – Crystals and crumbly texture very prevalent. A little bit goes a long way!
  • 6 Year Vintage – Our sharpest offering, heavily crystalized and very crumbly

About The Producer

Calef's Country Store

Calef’s Country Store

Established in 1869, Calef's has been "buying local" since Ulysses S. Grant was president.

In 1869, just after the Civil War, Mary Chesley Calef mortgaged her family farm and pledged her savings to open Calef’s Store in the front rooms of her modest home in Barrington NH. Five generations of the Calef family operated Calef’s Big Store until the 1990’s, including Mary’s son Senator Austin Calef. Today the traditions endure as Calef’s Country Store serves the local community as well as visitors from afar. We still pump our own molasses and honey, cheese is aged in our cooler, and our smoked Ham is mouthwatering.

Walk through our doors today and take a step back to a simpler time, when customer service wasn’t a gimmick, but the way things were done.

The wood floors creak with stories of lore, our wood stove warms passersby, the aroma of fresh baked breads and donuts entice even the healthiest of folks.

Jar after jar of penny candy tempts young and old alike.

Our Calef’s brand old fashioned jams, jellies, pickle items, bread and soup mixes offer something for everyone.

The wooden pickle barrel is still a focal point in the store. Our Ginger Snaps are renowned for their bite.

Next time you visit New Hampshire, stop by and pay us a visit, you’ll be glad you did. Store hours and directions.

Customer Reviews

Customer Reviews

nance
Rating: 5/5
Delicious cheddar
I grew up eating Wisconsin cheese so it’s been very hard to find cheese I really enjoy on the east coast that has the flavor I remember. This one does it. Excellent cheese.
Sat Dec 06 2025 18:03:01 GMT+0000 (Coordinated Universal Time)
Joyce Lewis
Rating: 5/5
Great Wicked Aged cheese
It’s The best. .reminds me of home I’m from Pennsylvania myself and we grew up on this cheese. And lebonan bologna as well which I sent away for as well which goes great with the wicked cheese. So my advise get some it delicious…
Thu May 01 2025 16:23:46 GMT+0000 (Coordinated Universal Time)
Lyn Backe
Rating: 5/5
TBD
Won’t have a review till my daughter tells me my ex-husband’s reaction to his 90th B’day present. I expect whole-hearted appreciation.
Wed Apr 23 2025 23:43:33 GMT+0000 (Coordinated Universal Time)
Rosanne Ianelli
Rating: 5/5
Fantastic cheese always fresh and tasty
I have bought cheese from Calef’s for years and I have never been disappointed. Always fresh and sharp! They sell the best products and I have always had an excellent experience. I even buy gift baskets during the holidays and they rave about them!
Mon Jan 27 2025 00:30:00 GMT+0000 (Coordinated Universal Time)
John Elliott
Rating: 5/5
Delish
Really the best cheese I have ever had in all my 84 years
Wed Jan 22 2025 13:18:59 GMT+0000 (Coordinated Universal Time)
Heather Davenport
Rating: 5/5
Wicked Sharp Cheddar Cheese
Thu Dec 26 2024 03:23:00 GMT+0000 (Coordinated Universal Time)
John Seigal
Rating: 4/5
Sharp. .. but not wicked.
Quality product
Mon Nov 11 2024 14:26:33 GMT+0000 (Coordinated Universal Time)
Cheryl Dixon
Rating: 5/5
Wicked sharp cheddar
So good! I shared with my neighbor, and I will be ordering some for him.
Sun Sep 08 2024 18:47:00 GMT+0000 (Coordinated Universal Time)
Christine Quirk
Rating: 5/5
Best cheddar ever !
Wicked ! Best sharp cheddar we ever had, we love this sharp tangy cheese , creamy , highly recommend I am a devoted Calefs fan !!!
Tue Feb 20 2024 00:54:36 GMT+0000 (Coordinated Universal Time)
Scott Worthing
Rating: 5/5
Cheese lover
My family has been enjoying Calef’s cheese since the 1970’s. We are looking fwd to the next 50 years !!!
Wed Feb 07 2024 04:08:18 GMT+0000 (Coordinated Universal Time)